He took 30 seconds to play it and review it. It's obvious his review has barely any depth and I scoff at it every time I read it.
Try it and tell us what you think after at least a week or a good solid month
"Every time [you] read it" suggests you have this thread bookmarked for whenever you feel like a good ol' fashioned scoffing.
If he had a bad first impression, I don't know why he isn't allowed to say so. It definitely doesn't sound like the most enjoyable way to get started on a server...
Okay, if that's how it will be badly implied, then so be it. I don't see the problem...
He's more than welcomed to say so, but I, too, can be equally critical.